News Filmelier

The new channel Filmelier+ is now available for subscription on Prime Video. Explore our catalog!

Actors who were (or almost were) Superman: Nicolas Cage, Henry Cavill, and David Corenswet.

What you will see here:

Superman is one of the most iconic figures in cinema and pop culture. He is a universal symbol of hope, justice, and humanity. Over nearly a century, several stars have shone (or tried to) as the Man of Steel. Let’s take a look at these actors, including Nicolas Cage, Henry Cavill, David Corenswet, and many others.

Nicolas Cage: The Superman That Almost Was

Nicolas Cage in costume tests for Superman Lives, a canceled film
Nicolas Cage was cast as Superman in Superman Lives, a film that never made it to production. (Credits: IMDB)

The story of Nicolas Cage as Superman is one of the most fascinating and mysterious behind-the-scenes tales in cinema. In the 90s, he was cast to play the hero in the project Superman Lives, directed by Tim Burton. This created immense anticipation. However, despite the excitement, the film never materialized.

Fun fact: Tim Burton wanted Cage to fully dedicate himself, undergoing months of rigorous physical training for the role. The director even suggested a rubber suit, a bold idea for the time, promising a completely different look. However, financial and creative challenges led to the film’s cancellation, leaving fans with a lingering “what if.”

Known for his work in action thrillers, in 2005 he chose to star in Grand Isle, a sci-fi thriller. In the film, Cage plays Lincoln Six Echo, a man who uncovers a terrifying truth about his existence in a seemingly perfect society. Packed with action and ethical dilemmas, the film keeps you hooked from start to finish. Grand Isle, is available on Adrenaline+, the platform that brings you the best action-packed films to dive into.

Have you ever imagined Nicolas Cage as the Kryptonian Kal-El? Did you know about this fact? 

Brandon Routh: The Superman Who Revived the Classic

Brandon Routh as Superman in a scene from Superman Returns
Brandon Routh portrays Superman in the film Superman Returns, directed by Bryan Singer.

In 2006, Brandon Routh donned the Superman cape in Superman Returns, directed by Bryan Singer X-Men (2000). Singer envisioned it as a tribute to the classic Superman of both the comics and Christopher Reeve’s portrayal.

Routh brought a more introspective character, carrying the weight of responsibility and hope. Thus, his performance balanced the strength and vulnerability of the character, reviving the essence that marked the first era of Superman films.

However, his career goes beyond the red cape. In 2010, he shone in Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, directed by Edgar Wright. In the film, Routh showed a lighter, more ironic side, winning over comic book fans.

Additionally, Brandon solidified his place on television by playing Ray Palmer in the series Legends of Tomorrow. This character allowed him to explore different facets, from science to action, further expanding his reach as an actor.

Fun fact: Superman Returns faced production challenges beyond a tight budget that affected visual effects, but Routh’s work was unanimously praised.

Henry Cavill: The Superman of the New Era and Multifaceted Star

Henry Cavill as Superman in a dramatic scene from Man of Steel
Henry Cavill portrays the Man of Steel in the reboot Man of Steel directed by Zack Snyder. (Credits: IMDB)

Henry Cavill took on the mantle of Superman in Man of Steel (2013), directed by Zack Snyder (300 and Watchmen). Cavill brought to the hero a combination of physical strength and emotional depth, steering him into a darker, more complex era.

Beyond the DC universe, he showcased his versatility in Mission: Impossible – Fallout (2018), where he starred alongside Tom Cruise.

Fun fact: Henry Cavill is known for his passion for video games and fantasy literature, influences that led him to the Netflix series The Witcher , winning fans as Geralt of Rivia. Additionally, he almost played another hero, Batman, before being confirmed as Superman.

His charisma and impressive physique, combined with dramatic talent, have made Cavill one of the most memorable Supermen in cinematic history.

Christopher Reeve: The Roots of the Myth

Christopher Reeve as Superman in an iconic flying pose
Christopher Reeve defined Superman for generations with his performance in the classic Superman: The Movie. (Credits: IMDB)

In 1978, the legend began with Christopher Reeve and the classic Superman: The Movie, directed by Richard Donner. This film introduced one of the most beloved and emblematic versions of the character on the big screen.

Reeve gave Superman a gentle gaze and a Clark Kent with contagious charisma, making the character more relatable and inspiring to the audience. His performance is revered by both fans and critics and set a standard for all future portrayals.

Moreover, Reeve showcased his talent in dramas, such as Sophie’s Choice (1982), directed by Alan J. Pakula, reinforcing his acting versatility.

Fun fact: Despite his successes, Reeve faced a personal tragedy that turned him into a symbol of courage. After an accident that left him quadriplegic, he became an activist for spinal cord injury research and passed away in 2004 at the age of 52.

Christopher Reeve’s legacy lives on through his dedication to turning adversity into hope.

David Corenswet: The New Face of Superman in James Gunn’s Bold Vision

David Corenswet as Superman in the new production by James Gunn
David Corenswet is the new Superman in the film directed by James Gunn, promising a fresh take on the hero. (Credits: IMDB)

This is the new great promise to don the Superman cape in the highly anticipated film directed by James Gunn — Guardians of the Galaxy and The Suicide Squad. Corenswet caught the attention of the public and critics with his performances in the series The Politician and Hollywood. This mix of classic charm and modern energy makes him the perfect choice to renew the mythology of the Man of Steel.

The project that unites Corenswet and Gunn promises an innovative reinterpretation that speaks to both long-time fans and new generations. This approach opens the door to exploring new layers of Clark Kent’s personality, deepening his vulnerabilities and humanizing the hero even more.

The anticipation surrounding the film is immense. David will have the challenge of honoring the legacy of Christopher Reeve and Henry Cavill while imprinting his own identity.

Other Actors Who Almost Wore the Cape

Several names almost had the chance to be Superman:

Cory Michael Smith — Gotham— was considered for a reboot that aimed to completely renew the Man of Steel. Although the project didn’t move forward, the nod showed that the actor sparked interest for his potential to portray complex figures.

On the other hand, Shaquille O’Neal, the legendary basketball star, was approached for a more comedic version of Superman. A bold idea that bet on the athlete’s presence to bring lightness and humor to the character.

Want to dive even deeper into the world of superheroes and the cinema that enchants generations? Keep following Filmelier for analysis, trivia, and exclusive news.

You might be interested in:

Follow Filmelier on Facebook, X, Instagram and TikTok.

Top 5 news of the week

  • All Posts
  • Cannes
  • Events & Awards
  • Mercado de cinema
  • Movies
  • Não categorizado
  • Oscar 2025
  • Reviews
  • Series and Soap Operas

Top 5 news of the week

  • All Posts
  • Cannes
  • Events & Awards
  • Mercado de cinema
  • Movies
  • Não categorizado
  • Oscar 2025
  • Reviews
  • Series and Soap Operas

Related News